Last month, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held in Commonwealth v. Cooley that a defendant was subject to custodial interrogation during an encounter with his parole agent. Because the defendant was never read his Miranda rights, the Court further held that the admission of the defendant’s statement was in error and remanded the case for a new […]
Articles
Article Categories
PA SUPERIOR COURT: Hearsay Enough for Prima Facie Case?
A three-member panel of the Pennsylvania Superior Court has upended the required evidence for proving a prima facie case at a preliminary hearing, holding in Commonwealth v. Ricker, 2015 WL 43810955, that a prima facie case at this stage in a criminal proceeding can be established solely based on hearsay. Hearsay is an out-of-court statement […]
To Err is Canine? An Opportunity for a Challenge to Drug Sniffs in Pennsylvania
Recently, the United States 7th Circuit of Appeals, a federal appeals court based out of Illinois, Wisconsin, and Indiana, released a decision (United States v. Bentley) that seriously throws into question the reliability of drug dog sniffs as a justification for a police search. In that seminal case, the panel pointed out that the dog […]
Expungement in Federal Courts?
A few days ago, United States District Judge John Gleeson of the Eastern District of New York ordered that a 13-year old federal conviction for fraud be expunged. The ability to have a previous state criminal conviction expunged is available by statute and common law in Pennsylvania (learn more about expungement here). However, it may […]
President Obama in Philly: “Criminal Injustice”
In a keynote address to the NAACP National Convention meeting yesterday in Philadelphia, President Obama strongly argued that mandatory criminal sentences for nonviolent drug offenders should be reduced or abolished all together, and that generally the system passing as “criminal justice” in the United States does not live up to that billing. During the speech, […]
